Economic Security
Poverty is a lack of choice, and mirrors the abuse survivors face on an individual level. Safety requires economic security. Nearly all survivors (94-99%) report experiencing economic abuse. Over 75% want help with financial matters as a result of abuse, but report multiple barriers to getting that help.
The purpose of this Economic Security Safety Landscape is to share data that helps tell the story of:
- The level of Concentrated Disadvantage: To what extent survivors face multiple, connected economic barriers to safety in each state. These factors are all associated with increased rates of IPV and high concentrated disadvantage may indicate poor state economic health and broad inequity.
- The Consumer Burden: Survivors are saddled with debt caused by abuse, take on debt for survival, and face credit and debt-related barriers to resources needed for safety (ie. housing). This is largely due to poorly regulated consumer systems. Levels and types of debt at the state-level can point to whether states have consumer regulations that protect survivors from the impact of economic abuse.
- Access to Economic Stability: Personal income matters in accessing resources needed for safety, but so does social and community support. Past unfair treatment and policies based on race and gender have concentrated wealth and poverty. The dashboard shows which populations have wealth, access to financial institutions, and protections in each state.
“There’s so much poverty in America, not in spite of our wealth, but because of it. Some lives are made small so others can grow…Poverty isn’t only the lack of income, it’s the lack of choice”
– Mathew Desmond
Economic Security Dashboard
Note: Dashboards are best viewed on a desktop or laptop computer in full screen mode. The layout and functionality may distort to fit smart-phone screens.
View Methodology & Documentation Doc for a list of all terms, data, and data sources for each Safety Landscape.
- Full-screen mode: If the embedded dashboard below is hard to view, click the “expand” icon in the lower right corner of the window to view in full screen mode.
- Filters (dropdown menus): In the dashboard below, there are five dropdown menus that allow you to change and refine data in the chart (from left to right): Indicator Type, Economic Indicator, Demographic Factor, Race/Ethnicity, and Year
- Using the filters to select/refine data in the view: From the “Indicator Type” dropdown (far left) select the category of data you want to view: Concentrated Disadvantage, Consumer Burden, or Economic Stability. Then select a specific data point from the “Economic Indicator” dropdown to view in the map and related charts. Some indicators can be further refined by using the “Demographic Factor” and “Race/Ethnicity” dropdowns. (If there is no data available in thes dropdowns, “no sub-category data” and “no race/ethnicity data” will appear in the dropdown window)
- A note on the “Year” dropdown menu: Some indicators come from datasets from different years. If map or other chart detail disappears in the dashboard, try selecting a different year.
- In the map view: Hover over states for pop-ups with additional state-specific data.
- In the State to State Comparison chart (below map): View how states are distributed on the data point you selected via all five dropdowns. Assess whether your state ranks higher or lower on the selected indicator, is clustered with other states, and/or is above or below the national average (the vertical red line).
- In the All States/Territories chart (right of map): View specific statistics for states, sorted by top and bottom. Use the slider and dropdown to display more states or change how it is sorted.
- Click on your state in the map view: Toggle to a state drill-down with the details on the selected indicator for your state, including general population and rates of violence data.
- Click the download icon (bottom-right): To download a PDF, image, or PowerPoint slide of the dashboard. Ensure you’ve selected the data point via all five dropdowns and the view you want. Bring this to meetings, share with partners, add your own data to supplement, and use it in your advocacy!
Concentrated Disadvantage
- What’s the level of concentrated disadvantage in my state (lower score means higher disadvantage)? How might you use this in your advocacy?
- Does my state also have a higher rate of IPV than others? (see Map 1)
- Are there indicators in the concentrated disadvantage category where my state is doing better or worse? Is anything surprising?
- What’s upstream from this? What policies, funding, or other forces play a role in creating or maintaining concentrated disadvantage in my state?
Consumer Burden
- What does the consumer data say about debt and consumer protection, generally, in your state? What does that reality look like for survivors?
- What barriers do debt and other financial hardship cause survivors (ie. housing)? Look at other Safety Landscapes to understand fuller stories of economic inequity.
- What’s upstream from this? What policies, funding, or other forces play a role in creating or maintaining consumer burden in my state?
Economic Stability
- What economic resources do survivors need for safety?
- Which people/groups have the most and least access to them in your state?
- Do survivors have access to wealth, mainstream financial services, and protection from financial abuse?
- What’s upstream from this? What policies, funding, or other forces play a role in creating or maintaining economic stability for some groups and not others in my state?
SEED-ing Advocacy
Click the links below to craft stories to fuel your advocacy & share your work, data, and recommendations with others. First, consider:
- What data stands out to you?
- How can this data be useful?
- What other data do you have to supplement what you see here? What else do you need?
- How can this data support your advocacy? Or how can your past advocacy efforts, insights, and lessons learned help others and improve the dashboard?
Use the prompts below to practice using dashboard data to craft and submit stories and ideas for systems change. You can also request assistance from CSAJ.
Use the prompts below to share your advocacy stories and best-practices with us. We’ll anonymize and add these as “map layers” in the dashboards in the future so the entire field can benefit. You can also request assistance from CSAJ.
Supplemental Resources
These additional resources are not meant to be exhaustive, but to fill some data gaps, and serve examples of data you may have (or could collect), including how it can be compiled and used in advocacy efforts. And they are meant to spur your curiosity to explore further.
-
Black Wealth Data Center National and county-level data that compares how race influences economic indicators that contribute to wealth
-
Prosperity Now Scorecard (2023Data, scorecards, and policy recommendations to help put everyone on a path to prosperity
-
Debt Collection Tracker A tool to monitor debt collection lawsuits to make visible harmful and predatory practices
-
Household Pulse Survey While experimental with limited sample sizes, data on a range of economic issues that arose during COVID-19 are available for expanded demographic groups, including LGBTQ+ and people with disabilities
-
The Economic Well-Being of LGBT Adults in the U.S. in 2019 One of the first pictures of economic well-being among LGBT households using federal datasets
Looking Upstream: Policy & Systems Change
Check back soon!
We are currently developing a National Survivor Economic Equity Policy Platform and will be adding more specific policy analysis to the dashboards and website.
Economic Security Landscape Dashboard created by Data Decoded
—
This project is supported by the Allstate Foundation
